An electronic signature request can fail for a simple email error, a missing field, an expired link, or an authentication problem. This troubleshooting guide gives you a practical decision path, explains what to record before resending, and provides a recurring checklist for contract renewals, onboarding, approvals, and other signing workflows.
Overview
When a signing request does not complete, avoid immediately creating a new request and deleting the old one. First identify the request’s actual status, preserve its history, and determine whether the problem is with the document, recipient, notification, authentication method, or signing sequence.
Common statuses include failed, declined, expired, canceled, pending, and completed. The exact wording varies between electronic signature platforms, but the operational questions are similar:
- Did the platform send the request successfully?
- Did the intended signer receive or open it?
- Was the signer able to authenticate?
- Were all required fields completed?
- Did a previous signer, administrator, or sender change the workflow?
- Was the document altered after the request was created?
Start by opening the request details and recording the status, timestamps, recipients, delivery events, error message, expiration date, and any available audit-log information. Platform labels and export steps change over time, so consult the current help documentation for the specific tool when a control is difficult to locate.
If you are still designing the workflow, review how to send a document for signature without missing required fields. A well-prepared PDF prevents many failures before a request is sent.
What to track
Maintain a small signing-request record for each contract, form, or approval. It does not need to contain sensitive document content; it should help your team diagnose problems and explain what happened later.
1. Request and document details
- Internal reference number or matter name
- Document version and file name
- Date and time the request was created
- Sender, account, or workspace that issued it
- Expiration date and reminder settings
- Whether the document was scanned, converted, or generated from a template
Do not replace the original file simply because a request failed. If the PDF must be corrected, save a clearly identified new version and note what changed. For scanned files, confirm that pages are complete and readable. If fields or text are not recognized correctly, the OCR troubleshooting guide can help separate text-recognition problems from signature-workflow problems.
2. Recipient and routing details
- Each signer’s name and email address
- Signer order, if sequential signing is enabled
- Whether a recipient is a signer, approver, viewer, or copied participant
- Any delegation or reassignment used
- Whether the recipient is expected to sign from a shared mailbox or personal account
Check every character in the email address. A typo, outdated address, alias, or shared inbox can prevent delivery or cause the wrong person to open the request. If the recipient has changed roles, confirm who is authorized to sign before sending again.
3. Events and evidence
Record delivery, opening, authentication, signing, decline, and expiration events when the platform provides them. Export or save the audit trail according to your organization’s retention procedure. A resend normally creates a new request, so retain the original request’s record rather than treating the resend as if it were the first attempt.
For background on audit trails and signature types, see electronic signatures explained and the guide to online document signing tools.
Cadence and checkpoints
Use the following decision path whenever a request fails, expires, or is declined.
Before resending
- Confirm the status. A pending request may only need a reminder, while a canceled or expired request may require a new request.
- Read the specific error. Capture the exact wording and any reference code before changing settings.
- Verify the document. Check that the correct version is attached, all required signature and date fields exist, and fields are assigned to the right people.
- Check recipient details. Confirm the address, signer identity, routing order, and delegation rules with the sender or authorized contact.
- Check authentication. If identity verification, a passcode, phone check, or access code is required, confirm that the recipient can use the selected method.
- Review notifications. Ask the recipient to check spam, quarantine, filtered folders, and corporate mail rules. Do not assume that a missing email means the request was never created.
- Confirm the expiration window. Use a window that gives all parties reasonable time, while following the organization’s internal process.
When to send a new request
Create a new request when the original has expired, the email address was incorrect, the signer order is wrong, the document must be changed, or the platform does not allow a completed or canceled request to be reopened. In the new request, use a clear reference such as “Resend—Vendor Agreement—Version 2” and tell the recipient which request supersedes the earlier one.
If only a reminder is needed, use the platform’s reminder function where available instead of creating duplicates. Multiple active requests can cause a signer to complete the wrong version or leave one request unfinished.
After resending
Monitor the new request from creation through completion. Confirm that the recipient received it, authentication worked, required fields were completed, and the final signed PDF and audit trail were stored together. For a broader paper-to-signed-PDF process, use the small-business workflow checklist.
How to interpret changes
A single failure may be accidental. Repeated failures usually indicate a workflow issue that deserves correction.
- Repeated invalid-address errors: Add an email-verification step before sending and define who owns contact updates.
- Frequent missing-field errors: Review the PDF template, field assignments, required-field settings, and document preparation process.
- Authentication failures concentrated among one group: Offer an approved alternative method or provide clearer instructions, subject to your security requirements.
- Many expired requests: Reassess reminder timing, signer order, expiration settings, and whether recipients know a request is waiting.
- Duplicate completions or conflicting versions: Reduce the number of active requests and establish a single source of truth for the final file.
- Declines without explanation: Contact the signer through a trusted channel to learn whether the document, authority, terms, or recipient identity needs review. Do not pressure a signer to accept a document they have declined.
Keep the original audit trail even when a resend succeeds. The first request may show when delivery was attempted, what failed, or why it was declined. The replacement request should be linked to that record with an internal note. Whether an electronic signature is legally sufficient depends on the document, parties, jurisdiction, and applicable rules, so escalate unusual or high-risk matters to qualified legal or compliance advisers.
When to revisit
Review this troubleshooting process at least quarterly for recurring workflows, and immediately when your signing provider changes its interface, error messages, authentication options, notification controls, expiration rules, or audit-log export process. Revisit it before a busy contract cycle, employee onboarding period, vendor renewal round, or recurring approval campaign.
At each review, test one representative request from start to finish. Confirm that the sender can identify failed, expired, declined, and pending states; export the audit trail; resend without creating confusion; and store the signed document with its supporting record. Update your internal checklist with the platform’s current labels and screenshots if those are useful to your team.
For the next failed request, use this short action list:
- Record the status, error, timestamps, and request ID.
- Preserve the original request and audit information.
- Check the document version, required fields, email address, signer order, authentication, and expiration.
- Choose a reminder, correction, or resend—do not create duplicates by default.
- Label the replacement clearly and notify the recipient through a trusted channel.
- Store the completed PDF, new audit trail, and explanation of the resend together.